Welcome to Miller Pizza Co.
At Miller Pizza Co., we take pride in crafting unforgettable pizza experiences right in the heart of Gary, Indiana. Our story began with a passion for quality ingredients and a dedication to perfecting the art of pizza-making. With plenty of sauce, flavorful sausage, and a soft, yet crispy crust, each slice embodies comfort and satisfaction. Customers rave about our signature Chicago-style deep dish, embodying the vibrant, quirky environment of our retro-style pizzeria. Whether you're enjoying a single slice or a family-sized feast, the warmth of our service and the richness of our flavors will keep you coming back for more. Join us for a nostalgic pizza journey!
-
622 1/2 S Lake St, Gary, IN 46403, United States Hotline: +1 219-938-7071
Welcome to Miller Pizza Co., a delightful pizzeria tucked away at 622 1/2 S Lake St, Gary, IN 46403. This local gem has garnered a reputation for serving some of the best pizzas in America, beloved by residents and visitors alike for its warm atmosphere and mouth-watering offerings.
At Miller Pizza Co., the pizza is truly the star of the show. Many customers rave about the generous portions of sauce and the uniquely flavorful crust. One delighted patron, Jim Whitaker, praised the pizza's delicious balance, saying, “Great pizza! Tons of sauce! Great crust and the sausage has great flavor!” It's clear that this establishment believes in delivering robust flavor in every bite.
Another standout aspect of Miller Pizza Co. is their Chicago deep-dish pizza experience. The restaurant captures the soulful essence of this classic with their medium stuffed pizzas packed with fresh ingredients. Isaac Stambaugh comments, “Delicious Chicago deep dish pizza in a fun, quirky environment,” highlighting both the quality of the food and the unique ambiance.
- Classic Comfort: Many guests refer to Miller Pizza Co. as a classic pizza joint. Johnny Schuenemane remarked on the “friendly service” and the “delicious sauce,” making it an inviting spot for families and friends alike.
- Incredible Flavors: Several reviews mention the standout sausage, which has reportedly become a favorite topping for many. Jill Stout expressed her satisfaction, stating, “It’s better with toppings for sure! The sausage is really good too!!”
- Accommodating Atmosphere: The restaurant is noted for its friendly and accommodating staff. Betty Boop1717 recalled how they catered excellently to a large party, resulting in a delightful dining experience.
- Retro Charm: Although the exterior may seem unassuming, many visitors appreciate the throwback vibe of the interior. William Good described it as a “quintessential pizza joint with retro photos of the area,” creating a nostalgic dining feel.
The locals appreciate the restaurant's ability to capture the spirit of traditional pizza-making while adding its unique flair. Bookie Tosh even drives from Chicago just to indulge in their pizza, which he confidently claims is the best in the whole country! With delicious options like the soft and tasty crust combined with a lively atmosphere, it’s no wonder Miller Pizza Co. has become a beloved dining destination.
If you find yourself in Gary, Indiana, make sure to stop by Miller Pizza Co. Whether you’re dining in or opting for partially baked pizzas to finish at home, your taste buds are in for a treat. Come for the pizza, stay for the atmosphere, and enjoy the company of friendly staff who are just as passionate about great food as you are. Truly, at Miller Pizza Co., every visit is a reason to come back for more!
Great pizza ! Tons of sauce ! Great crust and the sausage has great flavor! I will return !
Definitely a must try! One of my top favorite pizzas! I had half cheese half pepperoni and I think it's better with toppings for sure! The sausage is really good too!! Nice prices and good quality
Classic pizza joint with friendly service and delicious sauce (gravy)! Got the stuffed pizza with hot peppers, garlic, and onion. Definitely worth the stop! Choo choo!
Wow!! What an incredible pizzeria! This little gem is just off the train tracks in Gary, Indiana and the pizza, salads, and people are the REAL deal. Our cast and crew with Delack Media Group filmed and ate at this location and were delighted with both the food and friendly service. Highly recommend! Thanks Miller Pizza Co. staff. I'll definitely be coming back for more!!
Miller pizza is the best pizza in the whole America. Talking about the crust, it is soft and tasty, and to crown it the pizza source will make you finish the whole box of extra large in a day with your family. I have to drive from chicago to Gary Indiana to buy this pizza, how i wish they have a location in Chicago. Go and try them out, you won't regret it. For reference i do buy the sausage XL and the Cheese XL in case you're serving a large family or the keep for later.
Excellent service! We had a large party come and dine in and they were soooooo accommodating. Food was delicious and reasonably priced. I would go again!
Delicious Chicago deep dish pizza in a fun quirky environment. We ordered a medium Chicago stuffed pizza and fries and loved it. The pizza sauce was fresh and tangy. The staff was friendly as well.
Exterior looks a little run down but it is more of a throw back retro environment. Interior is quintessential pizza joint with some retro photos of the area. Service was friendly. They can partially bake pizzas for finishing at home, which I did. Deep dish was incredibly delicious. Tasted like a bit of cornmeal in the dough which is my fav.